What's the best 70's Pink Floyd album?

[Umma]

:strumma:

[Crazy Diamond]

if you're the one who makes the poll can you still vote in it?

[Umma]

yep

[Crazy Diamond]

and did you vote? cause i noticed that i was the first to

[cjules13]

if you're the one who makes the poll can you still vote in it?

Sure why not?

So this poll could've been for the best Pink Floyd of all time, because the top 4 best albums are in the 70s... Yeah , I know I said the Stones were before my time, but my Dad made sure I was up to speed on Floyd as I was growing up.

The Wall might be one of the best albums of all time for any genre IMO... :scratchin:

[Umma]

voting is strictly confidential... I can't divulge that information :D

I was surprised you didnt vote for a nice pair CD since it was a rerelease of the syd stuff...

(yes I voted)

[Crazy Diamond]

Umma, I saw that on the list, its nice to see more just the major albums but I confess, I didn’t vote for it.

Cjules, I was assumed that you couldn’t vote on a poll you started cause when I saw the thread Umma didn’t vote yet, no one did.

[Umma]

I didnt want to vote before your omniscience did

[Crazy Diamond]

hahahaahah

well as long as you know your place :P

[moonglow]

hummmmmm, I really could have voted for all of them but I didnt, but I should have :) Can you vote for more than 1 :rotfl:

[cjules13]

Hey Crazy Diamond - is your nick in anyway related to Shine On You Crazy Diamond? If so then you prolly are the biggest Floyd fan, and you prolly voted for Wish You Were Here?

[DudeAsInCool]

I cant believe Im the only one who voted for Dark Side of the Moon...

[Crazy Diamond]

Hey Crazy Diamond - is your nick in anyway related to Shine On You Crazy Diamond?  If so then you prolly are the biggest Floyd fan, and you prolly voted for Wish You Were Here?

Yeah it’s a Floyd reference, but in all fairness so is Umma and Madcap.

What makes you think that I would automatically choose Wish You Were Here? (not being defensive, just asking)

Dude: I would have picked more than one if I could, Dark Side being tied with a few others.

Edited May 19, 2004 by Crazy Diamond

[cjules13]

Yeah it’s a Floyd reference, but in all fairness so is Umma and Madcap.

What makes you think that I would automatically choose Wish You Were Here? (not being defensive, just asking)

Damn missed the Ummagumma reference... wow -

I've lost it...

So I thought you would choose that because that's the album the Crazy Diamond songs are on!

For me it's a tossup between Wish and the Wall. I give it to the Wall just based on length and greater detail in storytelling, but musically I'd almost have to give it to Wish.

[Umma]

This band are supposedly the new Pink Floyd -->Mostly Autumn

I have to admit they're pretty close a lot of the time. Check them out if you havent already.

[Crazy Diamond]

So I thought you would choose that because that's the album the Crazy Diamond songs are on!

Nope, but I can see why you would think that.

Has any ever heard of Luther Wright and the Wrongs? They’re a Canadian country/hillbilly band that made a name for themselves by doing a country cover of the entire Wall album.

I wasn’t impressed but if you haven’t heard them check them out and see for yourselves.

If you have then what are your thoughts?

[Umma]

Luther Wright and the Wrongs!!! what a great name

[Crazy Diamond]

...and there was only one Syd Barret...

You should go vote on the "Which Ones Pink?" poll

[gerald]

just got to say that animals is the greatest floyd album ever, though youve got to play it loud to truly appreciate the music, oh and to narrow things down even further i think sheep is the greatest floyd track ever, although i think there are a few close seconds on the wall ( hey you, mother etc) rogers amazing songwriting and daves guitar playing are at their best on all these tracks. going back to the barrett era the great songs are "let their be more light and astronomy domine" again these need to be played at high volume to fully appreciate them. now to move forward floyd as a three piece (loosley speaking) well i`me afraid polly dosn`t write classic albums with the skill that roger did so i am unable to choose a favourite maybe "on the turning away" is a decent attempt once it gets going. if you want to hear a classic floyd sounding album you need to listen to "amused to death" as it sounds more like a floyd album than momentary and division put together, just my opinion. :groovin:

[Umma]

opinion is what it's all about gerald :good job:

[gerald]

r u following me my little guardian angel

[Umma]

somebody has to keep an eye on you mice !!

[gerald]

i know i keep gettin lost but ile sus it out soon :strumma:

[mrmarco]

dark side of the moon

great album definitive pink floyd i think

;)

[rainbowdemon]

I cant believe Im the only one who voted for Dark Side of the Moon...

I did too!!

:D